George Psalmanazar: The Tale of a Fabricated Formosan

Portrait of George Psalmanazar, artist unknown, mid-18th century

In the annals of European history, the name George Psalmanazar stands out as a peculiar and fascinating figure. An 18th-century impostor and self-styled “native” of Formosa (modern-day Taiwan), Psalmanazar captivated and deceived the intellectual elite of his time with his elaborate fabrications. This article delves into the life of George Psalmanazar, exploring his schemes, the methods he used to perpetuate his deceptions, and the broader cultural context that enabled his success. It also examines the eventual unraveling of his fabrications and his subsequent life of repentance.

George Psalmanazar was born around 1679 in southern France, likely in Languedoc, though details of his early life remain murky due to his tendency for obfuscation. He adopted various aliases and personas throughout his travels in Europe, initially presenting himself as an Irish pilgrim. However, upon arriving in England in 1703, he reinvented himself more dramatically, claiming to be a native of Formosa.

Psalmanazar's exotic backstory and his purported knowledge of an unknown land immediately piqued the interest of English society. At the time, there was a growing curiosity about distant and unexplored regions, fueled by colonial expansion and the Enlightenment's thirst for knowledge. Psalmanazar capitalized on this curiosity, fabricating an intricate and convincing narrative about Formosa.

Psalmanazar's depiction of Formosa was a blend of outlandish fantasy and strategic detail. He claimed that Formosa was a highly civilized society with unique customs, language, and religion. His most infamous assertion was that the Formosan society practiced cannibalism and ritual sacrifice, which shocked and fascinated his audience. Psalmanazar went as far as to invent a completely fictitious Formosan alphabet and language, presenting it convincingly enough to be published and discussed by scholars.

In 1704, Psalmanazar published his most significant work, "An Historical and Geographical Description of Formosa, an Island subject to the Emperor of Japan." This book provided a detailed account of Formosan society, including its government, religious practices, and daily life. The work was filled with illustrations and the fabricated Formosan script, adding a veneer of authenticity that bolstered Psalmanazar's credibility.

George Psalmamazar: Description of Formosa. 

Psalmanazar's success in deceiving the English intelligentsia can be attributed to several factors. Firstly, his audacious self-confidence and charismatic personality made him a compelling figure. He adeptly navigated social circles, gaining the trust and support of influential individuals, including clergy and scholars.

Secondly, Psalmanazar was a master of detail. He furnished his accounts with precise and vivid descriptions, which made them difficult to refute. His knowledge of Latin and his ability to discuss theological and philosophical matters with educated men added to his credibility.

Thirdly, Psalmanazar's timing was impeccable. He arrived in England during a period of heightened interest in travel literature and exotic lands. The public's appetite for stories of far-off places, combined with limited direct knowledge of Formosa, created an ideal environment for his fabrications to flourish.

Despite his initial success, Psalmanazar's elaborate fabrications eventually began to unravel. Doubts about his authenticity arose almost immediately among more skeptical scholars. The first significant challenge came from the Dutch East India Company, which had trading posts in East Asia and access to more accurate information about Formosa. Their reports contradicted Psalmanazar's claims, but initial skepticism did not gain widespread traction.

It was only through persistent questioning and the gradual accumulation of evidence that Psalmanazar's story began to fall apart. Scholars who had initially supported him started to distance themselves as inconsistencies in his accounts became apparent. His failure to convincingly answer detailed questions about Formosan geography and customs further eroded his credibility.

The final blow came with the increasing availability of genuine accounts of Formosa from missionaries and traders. These reports exposed Psalmanazar's descriptions as fictitious, leading to his public disgrace.

Remarkably, after his exposure as a fraud, Psalmanazar did not vanish into obscurity. Instead, he embarked on a second, more humble chapter of his life. He publicly confessed to his fabrications and sought to atone for his deceptions. Psalmanazar turned to a life of piety and scholarship, producing works on theology and contributing to literary projects, including a translation of the Bible.

In his later years, Psalmanazar lived a reclusive and penitent life, dedicating himself to religious study and writing. His posthumous memoirs, published in 1764, provide insight into his remarkable life and the mindset that drove his grand deception. These memoirs are a rare example of a self-reflective account from a historical impostor, offering a candid look at his motivations and regrets.

To understand the phenomenon of George Psalmanazar, it is essential to consider the cultural and historical context of early 18th-century Europe. This was a period marked by expanding horizons, both geographically and intellectually. The Enlightenment was in full swing, fostering a spirit of inquiry and skepticism but also an insatiable curiosity about the world.

Travel literature was immensely popular, and readers were eager for tales of exotic lands and peoples. This created a fertile ground for fraudsters like Psalmanazar, who could exploit the limited verification mechanisms of the time. The lack of reliable information about distant places allowed impostors to fabricate stories that were difficult to disprove.

Furthermore, Psalmanazar's success highlights the period's complex relationship with "otherness." European fascination with non-European cultures was often tinged with a sense of superiority and exoticism. Psalmanazar's portrayal of Formosan society, with its sensational elements of cannibalism and human sacrifice, played into these preconceptions, making his fabrications more palatable and intriguing to his audience.

George Psalmanazar's story serves as a cautionary tale about the dangers of credulity and the power of charisma and detail in constructing believable falsehoods. His ability to deceive so many learned individuals underscores the importance of critical thinking and the verification of sources, lessons that remain relevant in today's information age.

Psalmanazar's life also offers a fascinating study in human psychology and the capacity for reinvention. His transition from a flamboyant impostor to a penitent scholar suggests a complex character driven by a mix of ambition, desperation, and, ultimately, a desire for redemption.

George Psalmanazar remains one of history's most intriguing impostors, a man who leveraged the cultural and intellectual currents of his time to create an elaborate and convincing deception. His tale is a testament to the power of storytelling and the human capacity for both deceit and redemption. As we reflect on Psalmanazar's life, we are reminded of the enduring need for skepticism, critical inquiry, and the quest for truth in the face of elaborate fabrications.

Sources

Ballaster, Ros. *Fabulous Orients: Fictions of the East in England 1662-1785*. Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2005.

Barker, Nicolas. *The Fortsas Catalogue: A Facsimile*. London: The Book Collector, 1991.

Craven, A. B. *George Psalmanazar: A Study in the Psychology of Perception*. New York: Columbia University Press, 1955.

File:Houghton MS Hyde 76 (1.1.Xix) - George Psalmanazar.Jpg - Wikipedia. 18th century. https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:Houghton_MS_Hyde_76_(1.1.xix)_-_George_Psalmanazar.jpg.

Howgego, Raymond John. *Encyclopedia of Exploration, 1700-1800: A Comprehensive Reference Guide to the History and Literature of Exploration, Travel, and Colonization between the Years 1700 and 1800*. Potts Point, NSW: Hordern House, 2004.

Keay, John. *The Honourable Company: A History of the English East India Company*. London: HarperCollins, 1991.

Mungello, David E. *The Great Encounter of China and the West, 1500–1800*. Lanham, MD: Rowman & Littlefield, 1999.

Psalmamazar, George. n.d. Description of Formosa. Accessed July 30, 2024. https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:Psalmamazar_Formosa.jpg.

Woolf, D. R. *The Social Circulation of the Past: English Historical Culture, 1500–1730*. Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2003.